Trending
DEAR DR. ROACH: Sixteen years ago, I had a minor stroke and a transient ischemic attack (TIA). Afterward, I was diagnosed with a patent foramen ovale (PFO). I’ve been taking 5 mg of warfarin ever since.
Now my cardiologist, as well as two cardiologists who specialize in PFO closure, say that I should consider closing the PFO because of the risks of continued warfarin therapy. I’m 79 years old and in fairly good health. I take telmisartan and atorvastatin. Should I consider closure, and what are the potential complications if I do so? — J.C.
ANSWER: Strokes and TIAs are sudden onset neurological events that are caused by poor blood flow to specific areas of the brain. Two of the major risk factors are high blood pressure and high cholesterol, both of which you’re being treated for. It’s possible that these medical conditions are the reasons why you had these neurological events. However, I don’t have enough information to be sure.
An additional risk factor is a PFO -- an opening between the left and right atria of the heart that was supposed to close when you were born. Up to 25% of the population may have a PFO. What we can’t ever be completely sure of is whether your PFO led to your stroke or TIA; however, the best estimate is that 0.1% of a first stroke is attributable to a PFO. For this reason, the surgical closure of a PFO usually isn’t considered in people who haven’t had a stroke.
A PFO closure is considered in people when the PFO’s a significant risk for them. In all studies that showed the benefit of closing a PFO, the subjects were under the age of 60. Closure has never been found to be of benefit when compared with anticoagulation. (Warfarin is an anticoagulant.) Closure is also riskier in older people with a 5% risk of serious complications, including atrial fibrillation, vascular complications, perforation of the wall of the heart, and death.
Your PFO is unlikely to be a significant contributor to your stroke and TIA because of your other risk factors: You haven’t had an event for 16 years; you’re already on a therapy that’s as good as PFO closure; and you’re at a higher risk for a complication of closure than most people in whom it’s been tested. For all these reasons, I’d be very cautious about recommending a PFO closure for you.
Even though your cardiologists are recommending that you consider this procedure, I’d advise you to seek the advice of your neurologist, who may have a different opinion about the potential benefits and risks of the procedure.
DEAR DR. ROACH: I’m a 77-year-old woman who’s in relatively good health. I’ve been taking thyroid medication for hypothyroidism for 54 years. In a recent column regarding MRIs versus CT scans, it was indicated that MRIs don’t have ionizing radiation, while CT scans do. Your response indicated that this can be an issue when multiple scans have been done over time.
I’ve had four chest CT scans and a PET scan after an evaluation for a cough showed a lung nodule. I’ve also had numerous ultrasound tests of my thyroid nodules. Should I be concerned about the frequency of these chest CT scans and ionizing radiation? -- N.P.
ANSWER: X-rays, CT scans and PET scans use ionizing radiation, while MRIs and ultrasounds don’t. There isn’t a large risk from medical imaging; however, I do recommend using MRIs or ultrasounds when they’re as good or better at imaging, as I want to minimize even a theoretical risk. However, doctors shouldn’t keep a theoretical (and probably very small) risk keep them from getting the necessary and appropriate testing.
Dr. Roach regrets that he is unable to answer individual letters, but will incorporate them in the column whenever possible. Readers may email questions to ToYourGoodHealth@med.cornell.edu. (c) 2026 North America Syndicate Inc.
All Rights Reserved