Trending
In the arena of American foreign policy, nothing sparks furious “debate” faster than the term “forever war.” As we approach the one-year mark of the Trump administration’s two-week war in Iran, the phrase has surged back within the bizarre alliance of isolationists, noninterventionists and anti-American pseudo-libertarians, all while Vice President JD Vance tries to rally them to his cause.
“The people who want it to become a forever war can attack me all they want. We signed up to not do this. We told the American people we would do no more forever wars. We are not going to stay there forever. We promised we wouldn’t,” Vance told Fox News’ Laura Ingraham.
Just a few problems.
First, it seems strange that Vance constantly speaks as if he is not a member of the Trump administration. If he were truly opposed to the Iran War (to the point that he is being “attacked” for it), he could have resigned. After all, given his obvious (and now kneecapped) presidential ambitions, what could have served as a better demonstration of his supposed set of principles than taking the ultimate stand? What actually happened is that he rolled the dice (even trying to sell the war after it was launched and engaging in laughable peace negotiations with Iran) and lost.
Second, the only forever war Vance’s coalition doesn’t seem to care about is the one waged by Islamists (including Iran) against the Judeo-Christian West. No matter how much they wring their hands, other wars are not forever wars on the basis that they last longer than we’d like. After all, the Hundred Years’ War lasted for 116 years … which is a long time and yet not forever.
Third, the actual reason Vance lambasted “the people who want it to become a forever war” rather than naming names is because no one is advocating for a forever war. Even the most hawkish hawks don’t want war forever. This is a lazy and insipid straw man used to smear anyone whose foreign policy doesn’t align precisely with whatever Vance is pretending to believe this week.
There are good reasons to go to war, and there are bad reasons to go to war. There are also good ways to wage war and bad ways to wage war. In the case of Iran, based on the information we have available and the distinct lack of effort by the Trump administration to either make the case to the American people or seek Congressional approval, this seems like a case of good reasons mixed with bad ways. Pointing this out does not make one a warmongering bloodthirsty maniac who wants a forever war, and given Vance’s impressive academic resume, he knows it.
The central problem with Vance is that he is a smart man pretending to be stupid pretending to be smart. That might work on the occasions that he emerges from the shadows (having done nothing for months) to deliver a social media dunk on the president of Ukraine or offer a pithy comeback during a media hit. But when it comes to issues of foreign policy, the American people are more than capable of understanding the reasons why Iran must be dealt with and understanding how the Trump administration has managed to mess it all up.
And if Vance really wants us to believe that he is some anti-war vanguard against a faceless crowd of forever war maniacs, he should start by stepping down from his role as Vice President of the United States, where he holds far more power and influence than any of his imaginary “neo-con” enemies could ever imagine.
Ian Haworth is a syndicated columnist. You can find his work on Substack and follow him on X (@ighaworth). To find out more about Ian Haworth and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com. COPYRIGHT 2026 CREATORS.COM